Let's Play Mafia, Day 4: Doing The Bandits' Job For Them

5

Sheriff Moose sat in his inlaws’ living room on the shore of the fishin’ pond, watching the sun rise and trying to take his mind off the problems that had been distressing himself and his neighbors. He wondered why they called it the fishin’ pond when everybody knew there weren’t never been a fish in this pond. Lots of people still liked it though, and it was a great place to gather in the spring and summer months. His reminiscing brought him back to the big cookout that @stardate820926 threw back in July. No one would’ve guessed that @stardate820926 wouldn’t live to see another. Eventually he’ll drag the body out of the water and mosey back into town to break the bad news to everyone else. But right now he just needed to sit for a spell.

So, who dunnit?

Original thread with Day 1
Day 2
Day 3