How is America Better Than Australia?

JasonToon went on a bit of a rant said
24

They say that the best way to learn about where you’re from is to go somewhere else. So when I saw the title of this post as a (kind of stupid) question on Quora, it got me thinking about what I’ve learned after nine months of living outside the USA for the first time in my life.

I still alternate between dizzy moments of joy at exploring life on the other side of the planet - not a common opportunity for a kid from my working-class St. Louis neighborhood - and sharp pangs of homesickness, shading into grief. I can’t claim any kind of objective expertise on either country. To be sure, Australians are a friendly, exuberant, funny, tough, and community-minded people, who have built a relaxed yet orderly society where even the lowliest only fall so far. They do a lot of things that I wish we would learn from in America.

But I’ve recognized at least three ways in which the United States is better. Here’s an expanded version of the answer I posted on Quora, meant with nothing but love toward both countries.

First, with its huge, diverse population, and its constant collision of influences, America produces so many weirdos that its culture is just vastly richer than a country like Australia’s could hope to be.

Very few countries can cover a range from Mark Twain to Jimi Hendrix, from Beyonce to David Sedaris, from Richard Pryor to Gertrude Stein, from Raymond Chandler to Charles & Ray Eames, from Woody Guthrie to Bill Watterson, from Hank Williams to Jerry Seinfeld, from Maya Angelou to the Ramones, from Muhammad Ali to Frank Lloyd Wright, from Roseanne to Prince… need I go on?

America is where jazz and gay rights and standup comedy and skateboarding and film noir were born, along with countless other cultural phenomena without which we wouldn’t recognize the modern world. American culture, “pop” and otherwise, is loved throughout the world for a reason. It’s immensely varied, innovative, and at its best, excellent.

Second, in anything to do with consumer goods, the USA is miles ahead of Australia. Prices, selection, store hours, and especially quality. I understand that Australia is a much smaller market, far away from everywhere else, so naturally things cost more. I’m glad that its workers make a much higher minimum wage (about $19 per hour).

Still, it’s shocking how much Australian retailers can charge for really low-grade crap. Maybe this sounds petty, but when your shoes come apart while you’re walking, or you lose 45 minutes trying to get a piece of junk bicycle pump to work, and you can’t get a new one because all the shops are closed at 5 PM on a Saturday, and even if they were open they’d probably have the same narrow range of overpriced flimsy plastic garbage… it doesn’t seem petty. It’s a basic quality of life issue. It matters.

(On a related note, don’t get me started on Internet service. Because my shitty Australian connection - in a dense, fairly affluent part of Melbourne, no less - would probably drop before I finished ranting about it.)

Finally, there’s the natural setting. Australia is a beautiful country. It’s far more varied and lush than the arid, angry red planet stereotype. The parks and gardens of Melbourne are wonderfully verdant, as are the forested hills surrounding the city. Australia also takes in the jungles of the tropical north, towering cliffs with ocean waves crashing on the rocks below, mile after mile of palm-fringed beaches, gently rolling farmland, and even some mountains just tall enough to get snow in the winter. I wasn’t expecting it to be so picturesque in so many different ways.

But come on. The sheer variety of spectacular landscapes in the US is unmatched almost anywhere. (Maybe China, Brazil, India, Russia, or Mexico.) Sorry to resort to another list, but contrast the Everglades with Mount Rainier, Hawaii with Maine, Denali with the Grand Canyon, Nebraska with the California Redwoods, Yellowstone with the Ozarks. It’s an amazing wealth of natural beauty that every American lucky to find within our borders.

Whatever your views on the world, whatever your politics, I think you’d be hard-pressed to deny these three advantages the United States offers over Australia. Australia is preferable to the USA in other ways, no doubt. But that’s not what the (kind of stupid) question was asking. And maybe any question that turns my homesick heart toward Black Flag and Key West and Breaking Bad and the Olympic Mountains isn’t so stupid after all.