How is America Better Than Australia?
24They say that the best way to learn about where you’re from is to go somewhere else. So when I saw the title of this post as a (kind of stupid) question on Quora, it got me thinking about what I’ve learned after nine months of living outside the USA for the first time in my life.
I still alternate between dizzy moments of joy at exploring life on the other side of the planet - not a common opportunity for a kid from my working-class St. Louis neighborhood - and sharp pangs of homesickness, shading into grief. I can’t claim any kind of objective expertise on either country. To be sure, Australians are a friendly, exuberant, funny, tough, and community-minded people, who have built a relaxed yet orderly society where even the lowliest only fall so far. They do a lot of things that I wish we would learn from in America.
But I’ve recognized at least three ways in which the United States is better. Here’s an expanded version of the answer I posted on Quora, meant with nothing but love toward both countries.
First, with its huge, diverse population, and its constant collision of influences, America produces so many weirdos that its culture is just vastly richer than a country like Australia’s could hope to be.
Very few countries can cover a range from Mark Twain to Jimi Hendrix, from Beyonce to David Sedaris, from Richard Pryor to Gertrude Stein, from Raymond Chandler to Charles & Ray Eames, from Woody Guthrie to Bill Watterson, from Hank Williams to Jerry Seinfeld, from Maya Angelou to the Ramones, from Muhammad Ali to Frank Lloyd Wright, from Roseanne to Prince… need I go on?
America is where jazz and gay rights and standup comedy and skateboarding and film noir were born, along with countless other cultural phenomena without which we wouldn’t recognize the modern world. American culture, “pop” and otherwise, is loved throughout the world for a reason. It’s immensely varied, innovative, and at its best, excellent.
Second, in anything to do with consumer goods, the USA is miles ahead of Australia. Prices, selection, store hours, and especially quality. I understand that Australia is a much smaller market, far away from everywhere else, so naturally things cost more. I’m glad that its workers make a much higher minimum wage (about $19 per hour).
Still, it’s shocking how much Australian retailers can charge for really low-grade crap. Maybe this sounds petty, but when your shoes come apart while you’re walking, or you lose 45 minutes trying to get a piece of junk bicycle pump to work, and you can’t get a new one because all the shops are closed at 5 PM on a Saturday, and even if they were open they’d probably have the same narrow range of overpriced flimsy plastic garbage… it doesn’t seem petty. It’s a basic quality of life issue. It matters.
(On a related note, don’t get me started on Internet service. Because my shitty Australian connection - in a dense, fairly affluent part of Melbourne, no less - would probably drop before I finished ranting about it.)
Finally, there’s the natural setting. Australia is a beautiful country. It’s far more varied and lush than the arid, angry red planet stereotype. The parks and gardens of Melbourne are wonderfully verdant, as are the forested hills surrounding the city. Australia also takes in the jungles of the tropical north, towering cliffs with ocean waves crashing on the rocks below, mile after mile of palm-fringed beaches, gently rolling farmland, and even some mountains just tall enough to get snow in the winter. I wasn’t expecting it to be so picturesque in so many different ways.
But come on. The sheer variety of spectacular landscapes in the US is unmatched almost anywhere. (Maybe China, Brazil, India, Russia, or Mexico.) Sorry to resort to another list, but contrast the Everglades with Mount Rainier, Hawaii with Maine, Denali with the Grand Canyon, Nebraska with the California Redwoods, Yellowstone with the Ozarks. It’s an amazing wealth of natural beauty that every American lucky to find within our borders.
Whatever your views on the world, whatever your politics, I think you’d be hard-pressed to deny these three advantages the United States offers over Australia. Australia is preferable to the USA in other ways, no doubt. But that’s not what the (kind of stupid) question was asking. And maybe any question that turns my homesick heart toward Black Flag and Key West and Breaking Bad and the Olympic Mountains isn’t so stupid after all.
- 16 comments, 26 replies
- Comment
Thank you for writing this. We need someones perspective of our country from outside right now.

/giphy USA
Australia has more deadly creatures on land and in sea
@lseeber Deadlier than an American with a gun and an inferiority complex? I doubt it.
@Nuurgle You always walk into a room and suck all the fun out of it? Geez.
@lseeber Spiders! Really big, hairy, ugly, venomous spiders <shudder>.
@magic_cave
Calling @Eluno?
/image Australian spider

@f00l Ewww! When I was in high school I used to organize moonlight horseback rides for some friends. The primary dirt-road path was bordered on each side by tall, swaying Australian pines. The guides always warned us that there were spiders in the trees. The pines are very tall and the path was very wide, so I didn’t worry too much, at least until the weekend we did a daylight ride. The spiders are often referred to as orange grove spiders or banana spiders, but they’re really golden orb weaver spiders. They make some of the largest webs known, about a yard wide and very sticky, and the females grow to about 6" including leg span. From horseback looking up at them, they looked dinner-plate size, and they were only 3’ or so above our heads. That was the last of the moonlight horseback events.
Check this source https://owlcation.com/stem/Facts-about-Banana-Spiders-Golden-Orb-Spiders . There are a couple of short videos and static images taken in Gainesville, FL, about 90 miles form where I am. They’re actually rather pretty, although I’d prefer not to handle one. The hairs on my neck are standing up as I type this, even though the last time I saw these things in the trees over my head was more than 50 years ago.
@magic_cave OMG banana spiders are something else. When I was working with adjudicated youth canoeing across the state of FL (and through the Okefenokee swamp) and those suckers were everywhere on the rivers. And you are right - huge webs. We’d paddle some places where we’d have someone in the canoe hold up the paddle to clear the path of the webs. Soft fluffy legs and body and on more than one occasion they’d land on my head and walk across and be on my face with such a soft touch. They’d hang out where there was another, much smaller but an iridescent and colorful spider, although I forget what they were called.
@f00l

/giphy lovely
@f00l Isn’t that a black widow? The spooky Aussie spider is the funnel web, esp. The Sydney funnel web.

@moondrake
I don’t know much about spiders, except that I like daddy longlegs spiders, and avoid the rest.
It could be a black widow.
I suppose I should have put quotes on my image search.
/image “Australian spider”

Well it seems using quotes made no difference.
Try again
/image “Australian spider” 3

@f00l Black widow is just such a recognizable spider, black with a red hourglass on her back. Had to exterminate widows and brown recluses (our scariest local spider) out of the basement one year so the furnace could be worked on. I generally employ a live and let live philosophy with predatory insects, but the ones that can cause real harm to people and pets must go.
@moondrake
I have never, to my knowledge, seen one in person. I thought it was a white hourglass, for some reason.
Seems my memory sucks.
K then.
@f00l Widows have a dangerous bite but they aren’t aggressive toward humans and are a comparatively large, recognizable spider so so you aren’t likely to run afoul of them by accident. Recluses are tiny, camo colored, look like a lot of harmless spiders, and hide in obscure places like shoes or shelves, so getting a very ugly bite from one is pretty easy. Their venom is necrotic, the bite may not even bother you at first, but do a lot of tissue damage and scarring later. Fortunately they aren’t populous.
Nicely done. Wasn’t expecting a non-instigating post based upon the title. Hopefully the responses will maintain that demeanor.
@RedOak Apparently not by the reply I got. One in every crowd.
In seeing the title, my very first thought was diversity. Having visited Australia twice and spent time in Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane, Hobart and Cairns, with some touring around these areas, the minimal amount of ethnic, racial and cultural diversity was unexpected. The aboriginal people we saw appeared marginalized, and other than Asian tourists, pretty much everyone we saw was white. Living in a city where anglos are a minority of only about 20%, it’s very noticeable to me. Don’t get me wrong, I love Australia. Sydney is one of the most beautiful cities I’ve ever seen, Cairns feels like an old friend when you arrive for the first time, the cities are clean and safe and everyone is very nice. But the absolute magic of the United States is our melting pot, where people from every nation, every culture, every race, every ethnicity, every religion, break bread together every day. Work together, create together, dream together, and shape a nation envisioned from many different perspectives to create a richer whole. Sometimes the puzzle pieces of our differences don’t fit together easily, sometimes we all have to embrace a little change, a little rounding off of our sharpest edges, to be able to fit together into one nation, but we are all the greater for it.
I’m curious about what the moving process was like. How did you decide what to bring? Did you bring things that you thought you’d need but now realize are just completely ridiculous? What do you wish you had brought but left back in the States? Did you pay a ridiculous amount of money to ship your goods there?
I only spent 3 weeks in Australia back in 1991. I loved it but I have to bring up the point Jim Gaffigan makes about Australians: “They like us (the USA) so much it makes you question their judgement.” LOL!!!
We have better chili, tex-mex, BBQ, chowder, blueberry pie, ice cream, junk food, girl scout cookies, tacos, and many other essential foods.
And we have better college sports. (I’d mention pro sports, but that industry has too much attention already.)
We have all that states people love to hate. Like MA and NY and CA and most especially TEXAS. Hah.
We invented and make the best use of monster trucks and SUV’s. And Harley’s. And we have more native breeds of horses. And more open roads to drive at over 75mph.
We invented digital downloadable audiobooks as an industry
We’re us. We kinda suck in some ways. We’re damned good in many ways. We’re fucking awesome in a buncha ways.
And we all have a long way yet to travel.
I hope.
@f00l Inventing SUVs was a crime against the planet, not a good thing.
@Pantheist
I know SUV’s have profoundly serious environmental drawbacks.
Esp as commuter vehicles. But in the West and other empty places, vehicles like that can be important to have around.
I am thinking/hoping that the environmental factors of our transportation will improve markedly. (Yeah. I know that’s iffy.)
SUV’s - either used as designed, or as suburban commuter vanity vehicles - are a small business compared to the full weight of many other current and historical shortcomings.
Let’s just keep getting better. If we can.
Let’s keep on the side of facts. Traditional ones. The non-alt kind.
There is plenty of darkness in the path ahead. We just gotta keep going.
@f00l They were made specifically to get around environmental regulations.
SUV’s and trucks made up 60% of all car sales in the US last year.
Here’s a population density map of the US:

How many of those 60% do you think are getting any practical value from an SUV?
They’re also stupidly unsafe for other people on the road who are driving more practical vehicles, which of course gives a lot of people another reason to buy one- best way to survive an accident with an SUV is to be in one. On the topic of accidents- they’re also too wide for many roads and clearly too ungainly for many of the people driving them.
@Pantheist
SUVs were the thing here locally a decade or two ago. Now not so much.
People tend to have either sedans/wagons/smallest SUV’s or pickups. And the pickups (those that I see anyway) get used as pickups. They are pretty justifiable at least some of the time. I see people having one small sedan per adult driver, plus sometimes a family pickup, a lot of the time.
Suburbans and Navigators have gotten scarce by comparison.
Yes SUVs and pickups and other large vehicles present a risk to other smaller vehicles. But they are not too large for the roads (at least not the roads around here). They prob do very badly in the crowded NE with much older and narrower roadways.
Our local roads are full of large work pickups every day (including plenty of duallys). Carrying and hauling machines, in visible work use. And our roads are full - I mean full of 18 wheelers every day.
Yes, it needs to change. Transportation needs to change. There are lots of things we might like that are bad for us.
In my original post, I was trying to keep it light-hearted. (I celebrated junk food, which may well be far more long-term dangerous and expensive to us as a nation than large SUV’s and pickups are.)
So I was trying to refer to the positive qualities and joy of stuff, and, yes, some of the stuff is questionable, and other of that stuff comes with very dark sides. I get that.
But I were going to lay in on the negatives about the US (which I’m not, at the moment, that would tend toward a contentious direction), SUV’s would be way down the list of a long list of serious problems.
We enjoy many things that are bad for us. Or very bad for us. And very bad for future generations.
Let’s just keep working to do better.
@f00l actually we have ZERO native breeds of horses. there were no horses in the Americas until the Spanish arrived and introduced them. (OK, They technically re-introduced them, but North American Equines had been extinct for at least a millennium…)
@earlyre
Yeah I know all that. I grew up living and breathing the world of horses.
Yes our native wild herds were originally from Spanish escapees, and to some small extent, Portuguese, French, and English similar. Spanish breeds of the time used in the New World are believed to be largely of the Barb/N African stock, with heavy amounts of Arabian heritage (based on historical records and genetic evaluation.)
And settlers and traders imported other animals, usually the more common riding breeds from Western Europe, esp Throughbreds, hunters, warmbloods, and hacks.
And here, farmers, ranchers, and breeders and the great wild of the 1500’s-1800’s made a mix of them, resulting, over time, in new breeds, among them the Quarter Horse, Appaloosa, Morgan, Standardbred, Kentucky Saddlebred, Tennessee Walking Horse, and other “typed” non-breeds such as the paint, cow pony, palomino, etc.
A list is here.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Horse_breeds_originating_in_the_United_States
I kinda wish we imported more horses from the Caucasus.
@Pantheist : I understand the points you’re rather ham-handedly trying to make, but there are a few that you’re missing. Let me give you another person’s viewpoint. Long ago I bought a Honda Civic hatchback. I drove a lot for business, and I needed to cart a lot of stuff with me on those trips. I loved my Civic. It was 13 years old when a guy in a old pick-up truck rear-ended me at a stop light and totaled it. I went back to the same dealer and bought another Civic, and I loved it just as much as I’d loved the first one. It was 8 years old when a young man ran a red light and managed to total all three cars, including mine, that were crossing the intersection. Fortunately, no one was seriously injured. Back I went to the same Honda dealer. By this time, though, The Spouse and I had both developed significant arthritis in our hips, and both my shoulders and my right elbow were painful as well. It was hard to fold ourselves up into Civic-sized cars and harder still to get out of them. It hurt to shift gears. And a lot of cars on the road were taller than had been the norm 8 years earlier. So we bought a Honda CR-V. It was a small SUV with great mileage and lots of cargo space, and we loved it.
We still love it, even though it’s now rather elderly, just like us. It’s a 2003 model year, but it still gets fairly good mileage (25 mph around town, 29-30 on longer trips) and it fits our bodies and our travel needs well. We’re now retired, so money is a bit tighter than it was in the past, and we hope we don’t have to replace it for a few more years. Since my son and his family moved about 450 miles away last year, we’re now driving about 10,500 miles a year.
The only “road” we’ve found a little narrow for our CR-V is a leaf covered, two-rut US Forestry Service maintenance road in the deep backwoods of North Carolina that we enjoy driving along on vacation. Most passenger vehicles on highways and local roads here in north Florida are about the size of our CR-V or larger; there seem to be more semis and double-trailer trucks on the interstates these days, which can be seriously intimidating.
I’ve always tried to find a good balance between environmental issues and my driving needs. In all likelihood, since I’m 70 and The Spouse is a few years younger, our next car will be our last car, and we’ll still look for that balance in what we buy.
@f00l tried harder to be reasonable with you than I’m interested in. I’m only sharing with you my reasons for buying a small SUV, and I’m not at all interested in a debate.
I have no idea how old you are, what part of the country you live and drive in, or how long you’ve been driving, but you seem to be a one-trick pony on the issue of SUVs. I just thought you should be more aware of the variety of reasons people buy SUVs.
@magic_cave
That’s good, because I don’t know why I should care about your reason, particularly when you begin your elegant argument with an insult. People do selfish things all the time, myself included. No need to be so defensive about it.
@Pantheist Either way, I’m done hijacking the thread.
Less terrifying spiders and snakes.
That’s all I’ve got.
@JasonToon & @moondrake ; Bravo! and Brava! I can’t imagine better paeans to the USA from anyone (anytwos?) after the past 12 months of ugliness, hatefulness, and divisiveness. Thank you both for lifting my spirits out of the depths of moondrake’s neighbor’s cellar.
Hey @JasonToon have you made it down to your local milk bar and had a sandwich and Big M yet?
How’s the pizza Down Under as compared to the States?
@heartny Oh yeah, I had forgotten. Aussie food was healthy and fresh, but bland to our palates.
The Rabbit Fence was a really interesting movie about Australia. Never been there but have worked with people who are from there. Two guys from there loved their hamburgers. Unfortunately the place we all worked (and lived) was vegetarian. So once on a grocery run (3.5 hours away - lived in NW Ontario at the time) they begged us to bring them back some. Of course they were seriously cold by the time we got back. This was back in the day of the foam little boxes McD’s would put them in. So they turned on the propane stove, put them in, container and all. Came back and got them out, thanked us for taking them out of the container. Nope didn’t do that. Container vanished in the heat. THEY ATE THEM ANYWAY!!
@Kidsandliz Rabbit Proof Fence, yes? They had these burgers where there was a hole in the middle and an egg cooked inside. I don’t eat ground beef so I didn’t have any but my friend liked them. They have these big crawfish called “Balmain bugs”. They put the meat on various things, so we saw many signs like “chicken breast with bug meat”.

No one has mentioned yet…
EVERYTHING IN AUSTRALIA IS UPSIDE DOWN!!

@daveinwarsh
Yeah. I’ve had that confirmed fire me by Aussie natives.
Must be weird walking around that way.
/giphy spock fascinating

Oz has it’s moments.
@f00l Playing this Friday at 3:30am on TCM.
Beware the drop bears. Heh. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drop_bear
I read the comment about the so-called Australian Pine trees. That’s a bluff from the ride-leader. Any pines that arrive in America are not indigenous to Australia (mainland or Tasmania). So that is invalid. Australia, including snow regions have eucalyptus as dominant species of larger trees and no pines, everything else is introduced. I reckon (think) he was scaring you.