Halloween Candy Showdown Round 2
3Well, it sifted out about as I had expected. A few of the races were tighter than I expected.
The Peanut Powerhouse Reese’s secures a fairly commanding victory over the holiday staple Candy Corn. Some people say Candy Corn will never see the big game but Candy Corn’s fervent fanbase supports it all the same.
In a similar fashion, Starburst moves ahead of Pixy Stix in a stellar display of fruit-flavored offense. Of note: Starburst is the only fruit-flavored opponent to move on to round 2.
In the battle of the nougats, the silky smooth style of MilkyWay’s nougat slid past the airy-whipped nougat offense of 3 Musketeers.
Smarties fall to M&Ms but make a respectable showing despite being written off. M&Ms punch above their weight in adaptability, but we’ll see what they bring to the table in round 2.
Snickers sees a satisfying victory over a relative unknown in Vanilla Tootsie Rolls. This game really allowed Snickers to display different layers of flavor in this matchup.
Butterfinger’s crunchy confection based attack managed to hold off its gummy flavored opponent leaving them to go sour-faced.
The fight between KitKats and Nerds was the scrappiest in the first round. Despite the disadvantage, fruit-flavoring faces in the current chocolate favored bracket Nerds almost manages to break off a piece but KitKats manage to pull ahead to move on to round 2.
Twix milks an easy victory over a Bear-ly gummed opponent offense. Twix will have a tougher time against a very similar opponent in KitKats that uses many of the same ingredients.
Alright, hope you had fun reading that. The updated bracket is below. Round 2 will see:
Reese’s v. Starburst
MilkyWay v. M&Ms
Snickers v. Butterfinger
KitKats v. Twix.
- 20 comments, 6 replies
- Comment
Starburst
milky way
Butterfinger
twix
Reeses
M&M
Snickers
KitKat
@RiotDemon. I think I just canceled your vote. Sorry
@tinamarie1974 lol, that’s ok.
Milky Way, Snickers and a tie between Kit Kat and Twix.
OK fine. I’ll vote for Kit Kat. Reluctantly.
@Kidsandliz you forgot about Reeses v starburst!!
@tinamarie1974 Nope. Didn’t forget. I hate them both. However I my vote can be bought with one of the candies I voted for…
Reese’s
M&Ms
Snickers
Twix
This round is making me think harder. I voted for Nerds over Kit Kat last round, and Gummy Bears over Twix. So if I vote for Twix over Kit Kat, by the transitive property, doesn’t that mean I prefer Gummy Bears over Kit Kat, but Nerds is indeterminate?
Now my brain hurts.
I’m just going to go eat a Reese’s
@ybmuG I would strongly suggest you get rid of transitivity problem by eating the offending candy until the problem is solvable or until you have no more candy left.
Starburst
Milky Way
Snickers
Twix
And I voted Milky Way for the caramel. Caramel is the best.
Reese’s
Milky Way
Snickers
Twix
as @ybmuG said:
Reese’s
M&Ms
Snickers
Twix
While they’re both on the candy racks at work, I seem to get M&M’s far more often than milky way…
in fact the last milky way i had was battered and deep fried with powdered sugar and chocolate and caramel drizzled over it… yum…
( they had a “fair food festival” at the fairgrounds for 2 days, to help the vendors since the governor cancelled the county fairs… thanks COVID!)
Reese’s
M&Ms
Butterfinger
KitKat
Starburst
Milky way
Negatory
Both
Reese’s
Milky Way
Butterfinger
Kitkat
Starburst
M&Ms
Snickers
Twix
Reese’s (fresh out of the refrigerator even better)
M&Ms
Snickers
Twix (and two votes if it’s a peanut butter Twix)
Reese’s
M&Ms
Butterfinger
Twix
reese’s
M&M
Butterfinger
Dark Choco Kit Kat (British version)
@nasman6 ok, now if you’re going to throw in international versions using better ingredients, my whole calculus is thrown off…
@ybmuG well, the regular version is good too
Reese’s
Milky Way
Snickers
Twix
Do we have any sort of presence from the United Kingdom on here? It can sway the results in odd ways.
The UK Mars Bar is roughly analogous to the US Milky Way
The UK Milk Way is analogous to the US Three Musketeers
The UK has no bar called Three Musketeers
The US no longer has a candy called the Mars Bar
(it’s confusing… I think I have this straight)
Reese’s
M&M’s
Butterfinger
Twix
Starburst
M&M’s
Snickers
KitKat
Reese’s
M&Ms
Butterfinger
KitKat
Chocolate, chocolate, chocolate.
Reeses v M&Ms, and Snickers v KitKat.
Reeses v Snickers.
Snickers for the win.
Reese’s
Milky Way
Snickers
Twix