Seriously? Local Wal-Mart closing after 36 years?
10http://5newsonline.com/2017/06/12/waldron-walmart-to-close-in-july/
I can literally see the Wal Mart sign from my back deck. It was built when I was <20 and I find it hard to believe that it hasn’t made money all these years. Don’t get me wrong, I really don’t care that they are closing except for the fact that some people can’t get prescriptions filled anywhere closer than 30 miles away because of insurance policies (my wife included). When WM opened they killed several small businesses in this small city of 3,500 (hard to believe, right?) so maybe they will come back. I suppose only time will tell. Similar stories, anyone?
- 15 comments, 33 replies
- Comment
maybe Dollar General will add a pharmacy now.
@cranky1950 Probably not, but there is a possibility that Harps Foods will. We have a local drug store that is “Powered by Walgreens” but some insurances don’t recognize them as a provider.
@jsimsace Check with your wife’s insurance, since it’s possible they also have refill-by-mail service available. It’s obviously not as convenient as driving a few blocks, but as an offset it will usually save you on any co-pays. The two companies I’m familiar with require that the refill be for 90 days. If your wife is on maintenance meds (which are usually more or less permanent) it’s pretty easy to use.
@magic_cave Thanks for the advice. That may be a viable option if nothing better pops up.
That’s the one of the big reasons that Walmart is (rightfully) vilified by many… because they do intentionally destroy local businesses.
(The others being they don’t give enough hours for benefits and living wages [which causes a massive number of their employees to get food stamps and be on some form of welfare], and they actively union-bust.)
It’s why I’ve boycotted them for 20 years or so. But I acknowledge I’m lucky I have that choice. Sorry for the hardships you and your friends will go through now.
@haydesigner We virtually boycott Walmart also; on in very rare instances will we shop there. We vacation in some pretty rural areas, and it’s horrifying to drive through small towns and find nearly every store in their “downtown” shuttered.
@haydesigner When I was younger and stupider, I used to boycott by shoplifting. (Buy a cheap item and sneak a more expensive one into the bag.) It was a lot easier when they were the first ones to put up self checkouts.
I think they’ve learned that it takes more than one person to check 5-8 self checkouts, because they have 2-3 monitor it now. However, it still takes casualties in our town of 30k, as we just lost another local grocery store.
@haydesigner Nobody loathes Wal-Mart more than me, but I think the reputation of “intentionally” destroying local businesses is not 100% accurate.
It would be “intentional” if they were using predatory pricing. I.e., selling at a ridiculous price that is below cost, and then raising it back once the competitors go out of business. The truth of the matter is Wal-Mart’s regular prices are low enough, that alone is often enough to drive the little guy out of business. It sucks and I hate it, but I don’t think you can realisticly accuse of them of intentionally killing local businesses.
@DrWorm I agree, if anything I blame local consumers. Wal-Mart doesn’t cause the cost of doing business for mom and pop shops to go up, it doesn’t line people up at gunpoint and force them to shop at their store, people make an active choice to shop there just as I make an active choice to avoid doing so if at all possible. Sure, I might pay a bit more for the same product at my local video game shop, for example, than I would at Wal-Mart or GameStop, but I choose to do so knowing that I am supporting small business in America, never mind that often times my local mom and pop will carry items the big box has no interest in due to specialty nature or low sales volume.
I’m not going to sit here in judgement of people living paycheck to paycheck (or welfare check to welfare check) on canned soup and saltines going to Wal-Mart to stretch their dollar a little further, but we need to recognize that the consumers are to blame more so than the corporation.
</unpopular truth>
@jbartus furthermore the rest of Walmarts policies people don’t like such as treatment of workers fall on the consumer as well. Walmart is told nothing else matters but having low prices and even when scandals are brought to light people keep shopping there. Irresponsible consumerism and people convincing themselves their choice on where to shop holds no power to rationalize continuing to do business with Walmart are responsible. The corporation might be making these choices at the end of the day but we as consumers are letting them get away with it by continuing to do business there. There’s a reason you won’t find a single Nike product in my house.
@DrWorm @jbartus There is some truth to that, at least historically.
Back in the days when I was young and so was Walmart, small towns in the Ozarks would get a new Walmart and the prices would be incredibly low. Coincidentally after all the local businesses disappeared, those prices would drift upwards, but never enough to enable the Mom & Pops to reopen. It was a great business model, but somewhat predatory, especially since now a lot of the money left the local area.
People appreciated the low prices, but the proliferation of minimum-wage part-time jobs with no benefits didn’t help any.
@DrWorm - But that’s exactly what they do. It happened in my town not that long ago. Unconscionable.
Dear Wal Mart,
@jbartus
Walmart plays games with pricing and suppliers and exclusivity. They try to bully suppliers into being available in an area only thru them, and they have it down to a fine art.
First they will sign on a supplier, and for a few years it will be great. Then Walmart, having cut all sorts of special deals and gotten the supplier to make special sizes and bundles available, will sell the hell outta whatever. Then once the supplier has contracts in place, and has ramped up production and hired people because the sales have grown so much, WM sometimes starts turning the screws. To get an exclusive. To radically cut supplier pricing. So that the supplier is suddenly faced with either going along by with WM (whose buyers are nice until they stab you), or downsizing to smaller than they were before they met WL, with attendant layoffs and exited contracts and loss of income and profit.
It can get quite ugly. And that’s all without considering the employee treatment.
I think they have been shown to move into a new market, be all nice for a while, then start the predatory pricing. But only as low as it needs to be. Then, when enough competition has died, the prices inch back up. They know how to keep it subtle.
The thing is, many people can barely afford to shop at WM, let alone other stores.
@f00l Well said.
@f00l gaining exclusive distribution agreements is common across many levels of business, not only at the big box store level. I used to work for a screen printing shop who had to sell Dolfin Swimwear in lieu of Speedo because there was another company some 20 miles away that had exclusivity. The company in question was a small mom and pop swim shop that was very regional and had very little if any overlap with this printer’s territory and yet the exclusivity was there. I can’t speak to your allegations of gouging suppliers, though most every business is going to try to trim costs where they can, but I’d be interested to read some primary sources on the subject. I’d be similarly interested in documentation of the predatory pricing, there should be case studies available after all these years that show a pretty demonstrative curve to the pricing if there’s evidence to back it up.
Either way, consumers are responsible for what they choose to do with their money. Money talks, as they say, so if you care about small businesses keep your money out of Walmart (and Amazon for that matter, pretty much any other B&M big box too) and support your local business owner. The problem is that people don’t, they make short sighted decisions like saving a whopping $30 on a flat screen TV, and small businesses perish. Whatever else you might say it is a truism that the demise of small businesses in a Walmart area is the result of choices made by consumers augmented by whatever Walmart and co. do. Walmart doesn’t post up gunmen outside of people’s businesses and force people to shop elsewhere, it is a free choice made by individuals.
As for your last, many people also choose to live beyond their means and utilize Walmart to facilitate such.
Our modern society is entirely too consumerist with many people considering things to be ‘needs’ that are, in fact, wants. We lack appreciation for that which we have and seek more than we have any real need for because we instill arbitrary and fabricated measurements for success and happiness upon life. The average life for a television has plummeted from 20+ years to 3-4, this is due in large part because of decrease in manufacturing quality but this decrease has been driven by the fact that manufacturers know they can get away with it because consumers are replacing them like crazy, always seeking the biggest, best, most feature-rich even though their current set has no issues. New phones are bought regularly a mere 1-2 years, if not months, after the prior phone was purchased and while that phone was still in good working order. People spend stupid amounts of money on clothes for their labels, shoes are a standout where a $250 pair won’t last you any longer than a $50 pair and yet people pay. People tell themselves they need these things because to them they’re status symbols and you have people forking over money they shouldn’t to buy these things to achieve some perverse sense of self worth, it’s a real sickness.
@jbartus
I agree with quite a lot of what you say.
I suspect pricing + convenience + aggressively pursuing biz opps are what make WM the master of its market space. All of these are reasonable biz pursuits.
I’ve heard quite a few documents ed stories about documented WM ugly buyer conduct over the years. I’m not tracking them down, but a famous one involved pickles somehow or other.
I remember another story from a retired guy (prev successful businessman) who created and made some sort of specialized sporting equipment. Someone in FL I think. M WM wanted it. Great. They wanted an exclusive. Great. He made plans to ramp up production, called off negotiations with other potential outlets, flew around making arrangement for manufacturing to meet up to expected demand.
Everything looked good. Then WM called. Last minute demand, never before mentioned. They demanded he cancel the tiny # of single-item orders from existing contracts he had signed before WM ever came to him in the first place. He refused. He said he would fulfill his existing contracts (a few one time, one-piece orders of customized to the customer sports equipment) and not renew them or sign new contracts. WM would be his only customer.
WM argued with him a bit and then dumped him. Shortly after, they had signed with some Chinese company and within a year had a similar exclusive product in the store.
I don’t know if intellectual property rights were an issue. The story was about how WM negotiated.
He was a sole proprietor before he met WM and could not afford to take them on, legally.
The whole thing cost him a lot of money. Not sure, but I think he finally abandoned the business and became a hobbyist.
WM buyer are notorious in wholesale and manufacturing circles in a way that not even Amazon can compete with at the moment.
Size and market domination can make it easy to be a bully, or to do underhanded things people can’t afford to fight, unless they are willing to have their lives consumed by the fight and still likely lose.
I don’t know if WM is better or worse now than they were 10 years ago.
Ok plenty do. Perhaps most. And many people either can’t or won’t evaluate the impact of their actions on the community. Many may not know how to do that.
But … how much time have you spent with the genuine poor who work full time amd always have, who live frugally and always have, who are so stressed and tired that they can’t figure out how to jump start themselves to better lives?
Plenty of these people out there too.
@f00l I know there are which is why I qualified it with ‘many’. I am under no delusions that there are not many people who benefit from Walmart’s low prices due to limited means, believe me. But I also know that there are plenty who buy their groceries with food stamps that own bigger TVs than I do.
Regarding the buyer conduct mentioned, my only response would be to note that the only evidence of Walmart not having mentioned it before is probably hearsay from the manufacturer (doubt Walmart would have commented) and while I empathize with what happened to him I can’t help but feel that either 1) he didn’t have a signed contract and invested in ramping up production etc. before anything firm was in place (because if he did have a signed contract that would pretty much have ended any such claim on Walmart’s part) or 2) if he did have a contract it had to be something he overlooked in the language. ‘Exclusive future distribution’ is very different from ‘exclusive distribution’, for example.
Either way I’m not really here to defend Walmart, they are a crummy company with crummy practices, but at the end of the day the masses still choose to shop there, just as they probably buy Nike products despite the many documented examples of unethical practices that company employs.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@f00l They nearly put Rubermaid out of business when that company refused to cave to the bully. Eventually they did cave, but the cost to that company was pretty high.
@f00l That’s how Rubbermaid became a Newell brand, they were at one time actually innovative and creative. They came to depend on wallys for too much of their business.
@jbartus
I don’t know if WM still has, or exercises in bulky fashion, the buying clout and contract clout they had 10-20 years ago. The markets have changed. WM has appeared to try to clean up its image somewhat. No idea if those are “deep changes” or merely cosmetics.
In you lived in a small rural town in a flyover state, you would cost yourself something notable in time and energy, trying to completely avoid shopping at WM.
Whatever locals might have done 50 or more years ago to protect their local biz environments, that’s gone now. The retail in county after county after county has centered on WM for that long. If you avoid them, you drive all over the place, and perhaps to the next town or county.
@f00l I was addressing the topic of Walmart driving local businesses under when they open a new location, not seeking alternatives in a long-established Walmart area, those small businesses are long gone and can’t be brought back easily.
I also boycott them. I hope you find other suppliers as I have.
That prime membership is finally gonna pay off.
@thismyusername And don’t forget about your VMP membership!
Also, check with your local grocery stores. Many now have in-house pharmacies, and some of them charge only $ for certain common meds. Target also has in-house pharmacies.
One other idea, for anybody who’s interested: check out GoodRx.com. They’ll price compare every pharmacy in your area and show you the prices at every pharmacy they find. AND give you a coupon for a discount. It’s primarily for folks without insurance, though, or for people who need a drug that’s not on their insurance formulary. The worst that can happen is that you spend 90 seconds on their site without any useful results.
@magic_cave
Thx.
@f00l Oops! I sort of left out the “4” in that message. Try “some of them charge only $4 for certain common meds.”
To hell with Walmart
(I sympathize with your scenario )
I also boycott them, along with Amazon. Actually local family just opened a pharmacy in my village of 2500 people. Competing against a monopoly of Rite Aid…Insurance companies are also part of the problem. Sorry…
We have an abandoned shopping mall in town that Wal-Mart was supposed to buy and turn into a (wait for it) Wal-Mart. They worked on the building for at least a year (I recall reading that most of the work was related to detaching the HVAC from a Home Depot that is technically attached to the mall), then they gave up. So now we don’t just have an abandoned mall, we have an abandoned and partially-gutted mall. I’ll be pretty shocked if anything ever actually moves in there.
I like Wal-Mart. It’s not their fault that they’re good at what they do. Well, I guess it kinda is, but it’s not really a fault. It seems very anti-progess to want mom and pop stores to stay in business when they’re not trying to do anything to make their business more efficient, more affordable, or more beneficial in some way to the consumer.
Innovate and compete, or die. That’s what my grandmammy always said.
@medz In the early days of Walmart, they shut out mom and pop shops by buying distribution rights to goods sold by the mom and pop shops. IE. Small town (~,10000 people), mom and pop kitchen store which had been open for something like 40 years closed partly due to not being able to sell Kitchen-aid products. It was more than just Kitchen aid, but it’s the one brand I remember. There was a whole news article on it in the local paper about it. Can’t find the source so it’s all hearsay.
This type of treatment is why I don’t shop at Wal-Mart:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkRXR-5zv2M&ytbChannel=A T
While the video is funny, it really is actually pretty accurate of my Wal-Mart experience. I have had a few excruciating exchanges with Wal-Mart, but the most over-the-top one went like this:
The female cashier scans my two items: a can of chicken noodle soup and a 32-oz Gatorade. She then matter-of-factly pronounces “That will be $672.84”. I plead that there obviously is a mistake, but she defiantly turns the electronic display towards me as “proof”. I reiterate that there is no way these two items could cost more than 10 bucks and she snorts “I don’t make the prices, sir”. Further attempts to explain the infeasibility of such a total are fruitless and I eventually give up and leave the store without my purchase.
@DrWorm
Well she should have called a supervisor.
Waiting for a supervisor to assist would have only taken a few hours or so.
/giphy waiting
I mostly stay out of Wal-Mart because… ewww.
Once, I went in for windshield wipers and another patron hocked a lugie right there on the floor in automotive. I just don’t want to rub unwashed elbows with that type.
Also, yeah, your taxes supplement Wal-Mart’s low prices because they don’t always pay a living wage, and any public assistance required by its employees is paid by us. Must be nice to have politicians in your deep pockets.
@PocketBrain
/image peopleofwalmart
http://www.peopleofwalmart.com/
@narfcake People of Walmart
I have never entered a WM store. Once, while registering voters with a group, I parked in their parking lot with my anti-WM bumper sticker. The cart guy started pointing it out to people walking by - most laughed.
Good times.
My daddy was a fine and upstanding human being, the kind that would stop on the road to help a stranger. He said things about Walmart that I cannot repeat, but that you may imagine. Among other things, he was opposed to them because of their anti-competitive practices, and their ugly tricks with wages (keeping most employees at less than full time so as not to have to pay for benefits, for example).
Even if I did not believe that Walmart was a soul-sucking monster, I would not shop there. I have, indeed, been inside (because I’d seen the People of Walmart web site, and was sure that it was an exaggeration…nope, it isn’t).
I don’t give them money. I have no blame for those who shop there; everyone gets to make those choices on their own. If Walmart was the only place to shop, I’d do without.
I miss my daddy. He died in 2008, and it’s still like yesterday.
@jsimsace Do you have Costco in the area?
@KDemo Thanks for the heads-up, but the nearest Costco is 3 hours away. It will all work out eventually.
@jsimsace - Mail order is also available from Costco, but I suppose you can do that with other pharmacies as well. If you’re curious, here’s the article I quoted:
http://www.savingadvice.com/articles/2015/02/02/1032625_can-i-use-the-costco-pharmacy-without-a-membership.html
Good luck!
I enjoy wandering around a Walmart store out of curiosity, as long as its once or twice a year, no more.
Those stores are often a huge PITA to shop in, due to size and disorganization, and employees who are invisible or overworked.
Even if it’s a “nicer Walmart”. (The stores are tuned to the individual neighborhoods to a degree.)
Sometimes it’s the only place that convenient. Sometimes it’s 3am. Sometimes it’s the only big place in the county.
Otherwise I avoid. Happy enough for them not to get my biz.
Have seen quite the customer sights tho. Entire families of 8 in pj’s and slippers, obviously w no underwear.
Persons who got out of a pool, swimsuit under long t-shirt, still clearly soaking wet.
Walmart treats customers and employees like crap, and abuse the hell out of their suppliers, but the stores do provide a sort of interesting social freedom as an experience.
@f00l I love the vitamin mishmash! they just have a row of 5 shelves and they shove the vitamins/supplements on there randomly.
WMPT: if you can’t find the supplement in one of the 4 possible locations they should be, just look on the top shelf, it will likely just be sitting there never to be properly stocked!
@f00l there is nothing wrong with going places in PJs. I once went to a gas station in a robe because I needed gas, wasn’t dressed, and it was cold out. Nothing wrong with not wearing undies either.
@medz
@narfcake Yes
https://goo.gl/DpGvXZ
@thismyusername Fuck!
I NEED EYE BLEACH!!