Pizzelle-a-palooza
12So because @Doooood asked for a good pizzelle recipe and since I didn’t want to co-opt @ironcheftoni’s fabulous recipe-a-day thread (my opinion, she can be permanent goat of she wants to), I’m sharing in a new thread.
One thing I want to point out here is that I do NOT use a non-stick maker. I’m sure they’re fine, but the consistent comment I hear from people who use them is that they are not as crisp as their grandma’s. That’s likely because she used one of these

And I know this may be a little anticlimactic, but I actually use the recipe that came with the maker. Mine is about 10 years newer than the one above, but still a good 40+ years old. I don’t know how it would work on a non-stick iron, but I’m sure it wild be fine. Trial and error is the best teacher.
For timing, I use a timer app one my phone, but even just a clock with a second hand works fine. First one out is usually under 30 sec. Then maybe 40, then usually about 45- 55, depending on the batter that day. You just keep monitoring and adjusting as you go.
Here’s the basic recipe I use, only I use butter instead of margarine.


For the black cocoa, I simply follow the instructions given. I do find adding ingredients typically lengthens cook times, but again, trial and error is the best teacher.
And seriously, if you want the best, get a Vitantonio. Older is best but even the newer ones are better than most others.
- 5 comments, 10 replies
- Comment
Sounds yummy! I have a pizzelle maker. It’s non stick since I bought it a few years ago. I got it in an attempt to make my own stroopwaffles and it did fairly well. Although when putting the caramel on them to sandwich together, I found they broke easily.
The small grocery store by my house has a deli and they always have interesting deserts in it. They had a pizzelle dipped in caramel and folded into a cone shape and then filled with a cheesecake fluff. Omg it was amazing!
@Star2236 I’ve never filed them, though somewhere i have my great aunt’s canoli form and have been tempted to roll some and fill them. You have about 10 second before they harden to much. Good with two people.
@Star2236 @ybmuG
I really do miss being able to bake, hopefully I’ll be able to get to it someday. 
You guys are making my mouth water! My first thought was to have Star mail me some of those cheesecake stuffed ones. OMG they sound delicious, cheesecake is my favorite!
@Lynnerizer @ybmuG
So far they were only a one time purchase bc for one it was $4
@Star2236 I have seen frozen, imported from Italy versions of those puzzle cheesecake cone deals at Trader Joe’s from time to time. Definitely good stuff!
@smerk85
Oh yeah forgot that trader joe has a version of them. I’m gonna pick them up next time I’m there.
Thank you! For the record, I plan to use a cast iron pizelle iron, although I wouldn’t sneer at a vintage electric one like yours. Mrs. Doooood uses a vintage percolator for her coffee, and likes the aesthetic.
@Doooood cast iron as in manual, hold-over-the-stove variety? That would be impressive… and slow. But fun! I have my great aunt’s, possibly her parent’s. They came from Italy in 1896 and may have brought it with them. As i typically make 3-400 around Christmas, not an option for all, but would be fun to try for a few of them.
@ybmuG Yes, actual cast iron. And no, I would not like to try 3 or 4 hundred that way. I collect (and use) cast iron cookware. Everything from your standard cast iron skillets and dutch ovens to waffle irons and bean pots.
@Doooood I think we suffer from the same malady…
Thanks for posting the old school recipe. I actually made pizzelles the other day with the cast iron waffle/pizzelle maker I had as a kid. This recipe had more eggs than the recipe I found online and other small differences. I use to tease my dad for keeping a box of every old cord he ever had but now I worry that once this 1960s cord dies I won’t be able to use it
@kodojr3 i find them periodically at thrift stores in decent condition, so i have backups!
Ahh, great idea. I hate to lose my waffle maker for sentimental reasons plus I don’t use any plastic or non stick ,except ceramic, for cooking. Thanks for the tip.
@kodojr3 Totally with you on the non-stick. I avoid it as much as possible, especially pots and pans. Cast iron - the original non-stick!