@UncleVinny I clicked the “something else” option and came here to comment that a ghost is better than all the proposed things because there’s a lot of questions a ghost could answer, like are there ghost books?
Then I saw your answer and thought a cookie monster is better than a ghost.
But then I remembered a cookie monster doesn’t make or bring cookies, just eats them and makes a mess, so I stand by my ghost. Or around it.
A skeleton is also better than all the proposed things, because skeletons are always happy and do a dance.
Also I have both a skeleton and a ghost inside me right now, but no mummies, zombies etc. So it’d be easy to carpool with them to the book club.
@ravenblack whattabout scary ghosts, tho? And whattabout creepy skeletons that, instead of dancing, rush clattering at you from closets you thought were empty?
@UncleVinny I mean, you wouldn’t invite one of the scary ones, right? There are terrible non-monster people too, and I also wouldn’t want to share a book club with one of those.
I suppose it depends on the rules of the question, is it like a monkey paw where you say you want a ghost and you get stuck with the worst possible ghost, or is it like actually inviting a thing to a book club, where you’d only invite the ones you’d actually want to hang out with.
I went with vampires because most of them are pretty old and probably have had plenty of time to read and form opinions and the like and they will have a lot of things to say about the books we read in the club so I’ll be able to mostly just keep my mouth shut and maybe nap.
@baqui63@mehcuda67 - Yeah, I have a feeling it’d be hard to keep a vampire’s mouth shut, and they’d drain the spirit out of everything. In fact I’d stake my life on it!
I would think a mummy would be like “mmmm mm mhhpp hhmmh” not the best at reading.
Zombie would be “Brraaaaiiiinnzzzz! gurgle gurgle”
Werewolf be “Hoowwwlll, nom nom nom”
Frankestein’s monster cant read.
But a vampire… who has been alive for hundreds of years would have some great stories! With their old style way of speech would be a great story teller!
@lilsrm123 - In the book, Frankenstein’s monster read Milton’s Paradise Lost an wouldn’t shut up about it. The problem is that he was a whiner who was always complaining and obsessed with his appearance.
@lilsrm123 yeah but a vampire would probably say really pretentious things and showing off how much he knows like “You thought Carver/Lish was a controversy? You should have seen Shakespeare’s editor!”
If Cthulhu was in a book club, it’d probably project horror stories into everyone’s head as he converts the other members of the club into his dark minions…
(Shelley’s) Frankenstein’s monster was actually well versed by the end, having read books and had opinions/thoughts. Should be an interesting book club with him, and his view of things!
@RiotDemon Yeah, but then it would really crimp your snacking choices and when you could meet. Though you could fly to the meeting and that would be cool.
Okay everyone said vampire because they’re hot but the obvious choice is mummy because even though they’re monsters they are also people from ancient Egypt, meaning I think they would have a lot of really insightful things to say at book club! They could give us a first-hand look at ancient history!
@trickynick Yeah I’m sure they would, but still, European history is more well preserved than Egyptian. I’ve heard plenty of old dead European guy hot literature takes, I want to hear a mummies!
Cookie Monster!
@UncleVinny well played
@UncleVinny Snack Attack!
@UncleVinny I clicked the “something else” option and came here to comment that a ghost is better than all the proposed things because there’s a lot of questions a ghost could answer, like are there ghost books?
Then I saw your answer and thought a cookie monster is better than a ghost.
But then I remembered a cookie monster doesn’t make or bring cookies, just eats them and makes a mess, so I stand by my ghost. Or around it.
A skeleton is also better than all the proposed things, because skeletons are always happy and do a dance.
Also I have both a skeleton and a ghost inside me right now, but no mummies, zombies etc. So it’d be easy to carpool with them to the book club.
@UncleVinny so much for snacks at the meetings
@ravenblack whattabout scary ghosts, tho? And whattabout creepy skeletons that, instead of dancing, rush clattering at you from closets you thought were empty?
@UncleVinny I mean, you wouldn’t invite one of the scary ones, right? There are terrible non-monster people too, and I also wouldn’t want to share a book club with one of those.
I suppose it depends on the rules of the question, is it like a monkey paw where you say you want a ghost and you get stuck with the worst possible ghost, or is it like actually inviting a thing to a book club, where you’d only invite the ones you’d actually want to hang out with.
@UncleVinny Even worse than a scary ghost would be a Patrick Swayze pottery-sexualizing ghost.
@UncleVinny For some reason I’d expect to hear “Eaten any good books recently”.
Werewolves are cool and have good taste in literature, everyone knows that
@billyrogers And werwolves are really only difficult a few days a month. And I’ll leave that there.
@billyrogers - I don’t know anything about werewolves’ taste in literature, but I’m sure they’d find YOU have excellent taste!
A mummy would keep the ending of a good mystery under wraps , for sure!
@LisaMJo ugh
@LisaMJo WARNING: Dad joke contamination
A werewolf 'cause who’s a good boy!?! Such a good boy!!!
I voted wrong. I thought it said Frankenstein’s mother, not monster. Or maybe…
My mummy used to read to me when I was small, so should be in a book club.
Ewwwwwww, book club. I’m only coming if it’s an excuse to get drunk at noon.
@nogoodwithnames You have to have an excuse? Noob
… I’m an Igor fan myself… At the very least he could hold my beer…
Stephen King. His stories show he’s a monster and his reviews will also scare the crap out of you!
I feel like I can trust Frankenstein’s monster to have actually read the book
I went with vampires because most of them are pretty old and probably have had plenty of time to read and form opinions and the like and they will have a lot of things to say about the books we read in the club so I’ll be able to mostly just keep my mouth shut and maybe nap.
@baqui63 Not sure if napping would be the best idea.
@baqui63 @mehcuda67 - Yeah, I have a feeling it’d be hard to keep a vampire’s mouth shut, and they’d drain the spirit out of everything. In fact I’d stake my life on it!
I would think a mummy would be like “mmmm mm mhhpp hhmmh” not the best at reading.
Zombie would be “Brraaaaiiiinnzzzz! gurgle gurgle”
Werewolf be “Hoowwwlll, nom nom nom”
Frankestein’s monster cant read.
But a vampire… who has been alive for hundreds of years would have some great stories! With their old style way of speech would be a great story teller!
@lilsrm123 - In the book, Frankenstein’s monster read Milton’s Paradise Lost an wouldn’t shut up about it. The problem is that he was a whiner who was always complaining and obsessed with his appearance.
@lilsrm123 yeah but a vampire would probably say really pretentious things and showing off how much he knows like “You thought Carver/Lish was a controversy? You should have seen Shakespeare’s editor!”
We already have @therealjrn. Why would we need someone else?
@Barney Yeah! …Wait…what?
I could probably beat up a mummy if it decided to attack
Some kind of large sea monster to keep us Kraken them bookses!
Well for starters the werewolf would only be a pain 3 days a month.
After reading a story about a dragon in a book club, I’m gonna have to go with a dragon. (It’s a pretty great story, too: https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13230340/8/Harry-Is-A-Dragon-And-That-s-Okay)
Being I have no desire to be in a book club (though I do like to read), I’m going with Mummy so there’s be one less person to have to listen to talk.
If Cthulhu was in a book club, it’d probably project horror stories into everyone’s head as he converts the other members of the club into his dark minions…
@Shinmaru So, is that a good or a bad thing?
@mehcuda67 good for story telling, bad for your sanity
(Shelley’s) Frankenstein’s monster was actually well versed by the end, having read books and had opinions/thoughts. Should be an interesting book club with him, and his view of things!
Vampire. Maybe I could convince them to turn me into one as well.
@RiotDemon Yeah, but then it would really crimp your snacking choices and when you could meet. Though you could fly to the meeting and that would be cool.
Chupacabra, that way there would only be one meeting, and besides it has the coolest sound in name.
Donald Trump. So we could have the pleasure of throwing out the biggest monster I know.
@rainbowharold wankity wank
Frankenstein’s monster would be funniest.
I DON’T HAVE TO TELL YOU PEOPLE NOTHING!
Frankenstein’s monster. He’d be really appreciative and into it until he goes off and kills someone.
Okay everyone said vampire because they’re hot but the obvious choice is mummy because even though they’re monsters they are also people from ancient Egypt, meaning I think they would have a lot of really insightful things to say at book club! They could give us a first-hand look at ancient history!
@sherbertzius - It would be interesting to have the opportunity to pick a mummy’s brains.
@sherbertzius an immortal Romanian wouldn’t have insight on things in literature?
@trickynick Yeah I’m sure they would, but still, European history is more well preserved than Egyptian. I’ve heard plenty of old dead European guy hot literature takes, I want to hear a mummies!
@trickynick - the way I heard it, Vlad had a certain territory staked out and wasn’t too sharp outside it.
Godzilla because, well, it’s Godzilla…
Frankenstein’s monster because why not?
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Cookie Monster
… Because cookies I
I would love to hear the historical perspective of the mummy on any book in the club and unwrap the old knowledge.