Coffee. No, I’m serious. Mint and the like are really good, and there are several other good options, but the Whataburger coffee shake was one of the best milkshakes I’ve ever had (reliably, across most of Texas - they introduced it during a road trip). My family got like forty of them in a week and a half. I’m pretty sure it’s literally just a vanilla shake with a standard coffee poured in, but they won’t make them anymore.
Just about anything from my local establishment Nifty Fifty’s. Eat your heart out…
Blue Ribbon Milkshakes®
Almond
Banana Blitz
Black & White
Black Cherry
Black Raspberry
Carnival Cotton Candy
Cherry Bomb
Choc-Cherry
Chocolate
Coconut
Coffee
Double Bubble Gum
Grape
Green Apple
Key Lime
Lemon
Mango
Marshmallow
Mint
Mocha
My Blue Heaven
Passion Fruit
Peach Paradise
Pineapple
Red Raspberry
Root Beer
Rum
Strawberry Fusion
Vanilla
Watermelon
Exotic Milkshakes®
*Almond Joy
*Baby Ruth
*Banana Nut
*Butterfinger
*Candy Apple Walnut
*Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana
*Chunky Monkey
*Coconut Crunch
*Fluffernutter
*Heath Bar Crunch
*Heath Bar Crunch Cheesecake
*Italian Rum Cake
*Peanut Butter & Jelly
*Peanut Butter Banana
*Peanut Butter Kandykake
*Peanut Butter Oreo
*Peanut Chew
*Reese Cup
*Rocky Road
*Snickers
Apple Cobbler
Apple Pie
Banana Coconut Custard
Banana Cream Pie
Banana Fudge Dream
Bananas Foster
Birthday Cake
Black Forest Cheesecake
Black Forest
Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry Cobbler
Blueberry Shortcake
Boston Cream Pie
Butterscotch Krimpet
Caramel Cheesecake
Caramel Crème
Caramel
Cheesecake
Cherry Cheesecake
Chips Ahoy
Chocolate Banana
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Chocolate Marshmallow
Chocolate Oreo
Coconut Cream Pie
Coconut Crème
Death by Chocolate
Dirt Cake
Egg Nog (Seasonal)
French Toast
Funfetti
Irish Potato
Key Lime Pie Cheesecake
Key Lime Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Mint Chocolate Chip
Mint Oreo
Mounds
Moose Tracks
Neopolitan
Nestle Crunch
Orange Creamsicle
Oreo Cheesecake
Oreo Cookies & Cream
Peach Cobbler
Pina Colada
Pineapple Cheesecake
Pumpkin (Seasonal)
Pumpkin Cheesecake (Seasonal)
Pumpkin Pie (Seasonal)
Pumpkin Roll (Seasonal)
Salted Caramel
Salted Caramel Cheesecake
Sea Salt Caramel Toffee
Strawberry Banana Split
Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry Oreo
Strawberry Shortcake
S’mores
Thin Mint
Tiramisu
Tootsie Roll
Wholly Cannoli
@chuckf1@cinoclav We have a place called Cook Out that does an insane number of shake flavors. In the summer they have a fresh watermelon shake. It’s pretty good.
@Fuzzalini I love an Oreo concrete (or whatever they may be called in your part of the country), but in shake form, I find myself continually being thwarted by small bits of Oreo becoming lodged in the straw.
Wife likes jamocha shakes from Arby’s. I like all strawberry and chocolate equally but had an orange dream shake (like an orange creamsicle) once at a mom and pop restaurant that was amazing.
Vanilla is the best first flavor in a brand, since all the other flavors start with the vanilla base. If you don’t think the vanilla is any good, then the other flavors will probably suck too.
I first read the title of this thread as: “Best snake flavor” - and while that seemed a bit odd, It was not particularly odd for meh. I vaguely wondered whether the item for the day might be Gummy Snakes, which would also not be odd for meh. When I finally looked at the item of the day, I said: "Oh, shake flavor! That was both more logical and less interesting. As for snake flavors, I definitely prefer “garden” over “rattle” in general, though I’ve never eaten any garden snakes.
Avocado!!
@curtise
They are really delicious! A must when I get pho
banana
Butterscotch.
/giphy Peanut butter
Albatross!
@Evansdoor With bits of noses and cheeks!
Shamrock
@katbyter Came here to say this.
In the (seasonal) absence of the former, the banana shake from Checkers is delicious, as is Cook Out’s Orange Push-Up shake!
@katbyter @PooltoyWolf Does the orange one taste like a Creamsicle?
@katbyter @Kyeh As its name implies, it literally tastes like an orange Push-Up!
@katbyter @PooltoyWolf Well, I had to look them up because I’ve never had one, but it sounds a lot like a Creamsicle - I love those.
@katbyter @Kyeh They are delicious!
/youtube Neal McCoy shake
Banana and peanut butter with fudge a swirl.
Strawberry, banana, or another fruit, to dissuade the guilt of drinking a shake.
Chocolate malt for me, please. (With [gasp] dairy protein.)
Chocolate peanut butter cup, blended with a frozen banana
A vanilla malt, heavy on the malt. Otherwise Chick Filet’s fresh peach shake.
Strawberry
pineapple 
But it’s gotta have chunks of real fruit…
Coffee. No, I’m serious. Mint and the like are really good, and there are several other good options, but the Whataburger coffee shake was one of the best milkshakes I’ve ever had (reliably, across most of Texas - they introduced it during a road trip). My family got like forty of them in a week and a half. I’m pretty sure it’s literally just a vanilla shake with a standard coffee poured in, but they won’t make them anymore.
A weight.
/giphy shake a weight
Just about anything from my local establishment Nifty Fifty’s. Eat your heart out…
Blue Ribbon Milkshakes®
Almond
Banana Blitz
Black & White
Black Cherry
Black Raspberry
Carnival Cotton Candy
Cherry Bomb
Choc-Cherry
Chocolate
Coconut
Coffee
Double Bubble Gum
Grape
Green Apple
Key Lime
Lemon
Mango
Marshmallow
Mint
Mocha
My Blue Heaven
Passion Fruit
Peach Paradise
Pineapple
Red Raspberry
Root Beer
Rum
Strawberry Fusion
Vanilla
Watermelon
Exotic Milkshakes®
*Almond Joy
*Baby Ruth
*Banana Nut
*Butterfinger
*Candy Apple Walnut
*Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana
*Chunky Monkey
*Coconut Crunch
*Fluffernutter
*Heath Bar Crunch
*Heath Bar Crunch Cheesecake
*Italian Rum Cake
*Peanut Butter & Jelly
*Peanut Butter Banana
*Peanut Butter Kandykake
*Peanut Butter Oreo
*Peanut Chew
*Reese Cup
*Rocky Road
*Snickers
Apple Cobbler
Apple Pie
Banana Coconut Custard
Banana Cream Pie
Banana Fudge Dream
Bananas Foster
Birthday Cake
Black Forest Cheesecake
Black Forest
Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry Cobbler
Blueberry Shortcake
Boston Cream Pie
Butterscotch Krimpet
Caramel Cheesecake
Caramel Crème
Caramel
Cheesecake
Cherry Cheesecake
Chips Ahoy
Chocolate Banana
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Chocolate Marshmallow
Chocolate Oreo
Coconut Cream Pie
Coconut Crème
Death by Chocolate
Dirt Cake
Egg Nog (Seasonal)
French Toast
Funfetti
Irish Potato
Key Lime Pie Cheesecake
Key Lime Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Mint Chocolate Chip
Mint Oreo
Mounds
Moose Tracks
Neopolitan
Nestle Crunch
Orange Creamsicle
Oreo Cheesecake
Oreo Cookies & Cream
Peach Cobbler
Pina Colada
Pineapple Cheesecake
Pumpkin (Seasonal)
Pumpkin Cheesecake (Seasonal)
Pumpkin Pie (Seasonal)
Pumpkin Roll (Seasonal)
Salted Caramel
Salted Caramel Cheesecake
Sea Salt Caramel Toffee
Strawberry Banana Split
Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry Oreo
Strawberry Shortcake
S’mores
Thin Mint
Tiramisu
Tootsie Roll
Wholly Cannoli
@cinoclav Whoa!
@chuckf1 @cinoclav We have a place called Cook Out that does an insane number of shake flavors. In the summer they have a fresh watermelon shake. It’s pretty good.
@cinoclav Okay, yes - I’m jealous!
Irish potato, though??
@Kyeh I assume it’s a cinnamon flavor.
@cinoclav Odd - if there are some sort of cinnamon potatoes, I haven’t had them!
@Kyeh It’s a Philly thing.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_potato_candy
@cinoclav Oh, okay! Those sound really good, actually. I love coconut.
@Kyeh They’re amazing!
Oreo.
@Fuzzalini I love an Oreo concrete (or whatever they may be called in your part of the country), but in shake form, I find myself continually being thwarted by small bits of Oreo becoming lodged in the straw.
@DrWorm Yeah, true. I generally prefer a McFlurry. Had one last night as a matter of fact.
@DrWorm @Fuzzalini Did you ever get one of the stroopwafel McFlurries from a couple of years ago? They were the best.
/image stroopwafel mcflurry
O.R.E.O.
Coffee shake made with chocolate ice cream. I guess you could call it Mocha but no one advertises it that way.
Second place: Cinnamon
Banana and peanut butter
Booty.
/giphy shake your booty
butterscotch if at Andys Custard… If at home… I mix margarita mix and vanilla ice cream and boom Keylime Pie shake… add Tequila if you dare
/giphy shake it off
Wife likes jamocha shakes from Arby’s. I like all strawberry and chocolate equally but had an orange dream shake (like an orange creamsicle) once at a mom and pop restaurant that was amazing.
Chocolate Peanut butter
https://www.eatpdq.com/menu/hand-spun-shakes/chocolate-peanut-butter
Quince!
/giphy foods that start with the letter q Alex!
@sillyheathen quarter pounder
blended into a smoothie/shake
@duodec
/giphy delicious!
@duodec
Quail mousse?
Vanilla malt.
Vanilla is the best first flavor in a brand, since all the other flavors start with the vanilla base. If you don’t think the vanilla is any good, then the other flavors will probably suck too.
Sonic has a Coconut Cream Pie shake I’m pretty fond of.
Steak N Shake has offered a Speculoos (Dutch Windmill Cookie) shake that is fantastic.
How could I forget this one
Even a place like chicago has to have some great things about it (and you can get these in the suburbs so don’t have to travel into the city)
I first read the title of this thread as: “Best snake flavor” - and while that seemed a bit odd, It was not particularly odd for meh. I vaguely wondered whether the item for the day might be Gummy Snakes, which would also not be odd for meh. When I finally looked at the item of the day, I said: "Oh, shake flavor! That was both more logical and less interesting. As for snake flavors, I definitely prefer “garden” over “rattle” in general, though I’ve never eaten any garden snakes.