Anybody Here Familiar With European Debt Collection Laws?
2I need some advice, but due to various bits of the story, I would prefer not to discuss the situation here.
All I’ll say here is that a debt collection agency refuses to prove I am the debtor, even though numerous things don’t fully add up.
Anybody here who I can email for help? We’ll use alt emails if you prefer. I just want to get this over with.
- 15 comments, 31 replies
- Comment
Also, would I also be able to claim help from US Consumer Protection Laws?
no particular advice, but i did see this:
“Dave Ramsey suggests keeping an air horn next to the phone”
@carl669
As tempting as that is, they’ve been using other methods of communicating with me.
I’ve gotten 2 letters in the mail (on the same day) from the company claiming I owe money, as well as emails from both them, and their collection agency.
@TickledLizard
Are you in the US currently? Then US law applies. This won’t stop them from sending you letters, unless you go the all the steps. And then the can ignore the law, to a point, if they are outside the US. But I don’t think they can get thing from you or mess up your credit. Not an expert tho.
This sounds like a “needs expert” things it if gets troublesome.
Just a thought.
I THINK!!! (Emphasis on think)
PERHAPS
You can them in small claims court in your jurisdiction. That’s fairly cheap. As a biz they pretty much have to hire a lawyer in your jurisdiction to defend. This is expensive for them. Really expensive. A court can issue a judgement over this.
I AM NOT A LAWYER AND DONT KNOW ANY AREA OF LAW.
Don’t act without research.
Also not all foreign companies are ethical, some might even fake evidence. But many are ethical
@f00l
more thoughts. If you go thru the proper channels contact all the agencies and get no satisfaction, sometimes you can contact your local Congressperson’s office. Sometimes they help, sometimes they don’t. Even if you love or despise them.
Any sometimes next election, they want $, so use Google Voice or Skype or whatever if you care about that, when you call Washington.
…
If you are dealing with a normal dept of a normal company, it made not be as bad as I recount below. If you are dealing with a collections dept or a collection agency, they may not care if you owe the debt or not. They simply mean to make you pay. Some companies literally invent debts out of thin air, let them age till in “collection”, then use collection agency tactics to try to get money.
Much depends on the laws of your state, as well.
When they contact you, acknowledge exactly nothing. Not even your name, if they don’t have it already.
Get info from them. Don’t give any info to them of any kind. They may well not be rational ir fair, them may simply be a machine that eats your energy. Don’t discuss with them. Don’t reason with them. Don’t argue with them. Give them nothing.
Make sure every single contact is completely under your control and do not cooperate in any way. Nor even to confirm the date or the weather.
Don’t deal with them at all if you can help it.
You just have to be 100% total jerk. Like a part in a play - you put on the costume, you take it off and try to be human again.
For more info google “collections scripts” and find forums where people who work in the industry recount experiences. You must be your own lawyer, judge, and police officer in every encounter. Always behave as tho they are 150% in the wrong. If you can’t do this, try to find a friend or fam member who is a hard-ass and can take on these conversations for you. Someone who will be an enormous concrete wall. Do this for yourself if you can. Learn to do it.
The people who work in this industry are trained to be more relentless than a shark, and they are punished, or lose their jobs, if they are not pure evil. They made be paid on commission based on what they collect. Some of them will plead w you to pay so they won’t lose their jobs.
Mostly they go away when they figure out you won’t play their game. Unfortunately, not always.
No idea here; a quick search found this thread:
http://www.expertlaw.com/forums/showthread.php?t=184255
Even if it’s something legitimate, local laws and statue of limitations can come into play, voiding such collections.
@narfcake
Thanks for that site.
Made a post there, so I’m hoping I could get help.
@TickledLizard
With some caution, and take it for what you paid for it, Reddit?
@narfcake
Someone there told me not to respond since a real collection agency wouldn’t initially contact me via email.
So, that’s what I’ll do for now.
@TickledLizard
If they aren’t going to sue you or hit your credit report, my take would be Ignore Ignore Ignore and Never Respond.
This assumes they don’t have a legit case. Legit cases are new complex. Ideally one would deal with them. Sometimes you are punished for trying to do the right thing. So, individual decisions re those.
@TickledLizard the one thing not to ignore is if you get a summons to court. If you don’t show up then the other side wins by default.
@Kidsandliz
OK, though naturally I am hoping that this gets resolved before it comes to that.
@TickledLizard
Companies will threaten court when they have no intention of going near court.
Likely, going to court will cost them more money than they could ever gain, even if they won. So only a tiny number of debt disputes wind up in court, and those are almost always for a lot of money.
So threats to go to court are meaningless. Letters from lawyers are usually meaningless too - companies hire law firms to generate scary letters - this is cheap for them. A really awful collections unit will lie, pretend all sorts of nonsense, threaten all sorts of bs, possibly even try to harass a victim thru family, friends, neighbors, job - and this last is completely illegal, but some do it anyway.
Much phony or questionable-whether-legit debt stuff goes away if they can’t get a response from their target.
Keep an eye on your credit report tho.
@f00l Specifically,
Thinking of filing a complaint with the CFPB, but I don’t know if they cover complaints against foreign companies.
I doubt US Consumer Protection would help you, but I’m curious how foreign debt could affect you? Credit scores are national (or am I wrong about that?), and any action to actually collect would require proof. I would be tempted to just ignore them if they refuse to positively identify you, unless your dealing with some shady lenders.
/giphy loan shark
@MrGlass Credit scores are indeed national. I have separate Canadian and US scores. Anything I do in one country has no effect on the rating on the other, although that wouldn’t prevent US entities from reporting to Canadian bureaux, or vice versa.
@MrGlass
/giphy shark loan
Just filed a complaint with the NY Attorney General’s office.
@TickledLizard
And the CFPB
SURPRISE!!!
Two more letters expecting payment. On the bright side, now I have more physical proof besides the emails I sent to CFPB and Attorney Generals office.
@TickledLizard Sending emails is a good start. Follow up with physical letters to the AG & CFPB, registered. Cost will be minimal if you don’t require a signature. What does Google say about the company and its putative client? Have you looked at the State Department’s site for the country to see whether they have a reporting process you can add?
Was looking into this company more.
People have had similar issues for the last two years.
Although I read something on the website of the company which is bugging me, which made me laugh hysterically.
We’ve gotten a few of these invoices demanding payment or they’ll go after us from companies in England. Knowing that we’ve never done business with anyone in England, we’ve always ignored them. I think what we get is similar to the Nigerian prince scam.
If the “debt” has no possible validity, this is just a new scam. Ignore.
Esp if you find other people reporting the same garbage behavior.
If nothing but a scam: Do report them to various consumer agencies - local, state, federal, independent. Also perhaps to your Congressperson and Senators, state and federal. Consider reporting them to the agency if their wn country, tho they may not be based where they say they are.
Also if you have the energy, you might notify you local newspaper and tv stations, or even to Fox, Cnn, MSNBC, CNBC, etc. much depends on how much energy you have to use against them.
Update:
I got a letter from the Attorney General’s office. Turns out, they forwarded my complaint to the FTC. I suppose I should have seen that coming.
Wow, they are really persistent and annoying.
It then goes on to tell me to pay etc…
@PlacidPenguin um… so this is the first time you gave info about who this is. Did you ever do business with UseNeXT?
@jbartus
No.
@PlacidPenguin not even the free trial?
@jbartus
I didn’t even hear of useNext until these emails started.
@PlacidPenguin Weird.
@jbartus
Not really sure what to do.
Curious as to how this will end.
@PlacidPenguin why do they put the commas in such weird places? any why only use one sentence in each paragraph? i smell scam.
@carl669
The sad part is, society is encouraging horrible grammar. Have you seen how kids (and adults) use grammar in texts, and on social media?
Curiosity questions:
Do the letters have your correct name and address and other particulars?
Dos the amount or service they are claiming you owe seem to be reasonable in view of the services they offer and what they charge?
Does the demand for payment come from a legal entity representing UseNect directly, or representing someone to whom the debt has been sold?
More serious questions
Could someone you know IRL have set you up somehow? Or used your info?
Have you reason to suspect identity theft?
Since all the companies and organizations that hold our info all appear to be hackable, and since the big data companies sell our info so freely, I believe that phony demands for payment of phony bills - and real demands for payment of bills created by ID theft will engulf us. Your experience in this matter may be a bellwether.
In any case do not communicate w them or answer their questions.
Are you seeing lots of similar stories about phony bills from them, or just a few? Is there a Reddit thread? How have people resolved this, if someone has? Do you see any indication that this company is honorable and honest?
There are record-call apps for android. If you call anyone about this, tho company, anyone else, record the call.
In your case my real worries would be my credit report and a lawsuit. Tho I can’t imagine them filing suit over a usenet bill.
Are you resident in NY state? How well protected are you by state law?
If they don’t file suit or mess w your credit report, all they are is a nuisance.
@f00l
Yes.
No clue. Its confusing though, because according to their site, payment is necessary before each month. Otherwise service won’t be provided. So regardless of who signed me up, this doesn’t make sense.
Yes.
No clue.
No clue.
Not really.
Lots. No clue. They sent unsigned letters demanding an end to all contact if it couldn’t be proven 100% that it was them. No.
Should I really be that worried about a lawsuit? The amount that they’re claiming wouldn’t justify all of the expenses for them. Still though…
Yes. Didn’t check.
I looked on my PayPal account, there was never anything to them. Would it be to my advantage though that the name they are using is not my “legal” name?
@PlacidPenguin One of the pieces of advice that I saw that made sense to me: if it wasn’t sent registered mail or other confirmed delivery, that letter never got to you. They’re not going to take you to court for a couple hundred dollars, and they will eventually give up. If they try to ding your credit or take other detrimental action then go after them.
@PlacidPenguin
I am wondering if someone got a casual or old version of your name, your email address, and bought service using a phony credit card or other payment account.
I can’t imagine suing over a Usenet bill. Unless you were a reseller buying industrial level services.
It’s starting to sound to me like someone used your id to scam them, they know it, and the collection attempts are just a shot in the dark, they are hopking you just pay and they won’t have to take the loss.
I bet this happens to them thousands of times a day. Same as porn sites, which get hit this way constantly. And Usenet is a primary source of perm and pirated materials, so …
In Texas all corporate threats to sue are pretty much nonsense unless the debt is many thousands. They can’t collect and the suit would cost them more than they could get in any case.
There are exceptions, for home repairs, car repairs, stiff where the debtor can easily get a lien, very large debts. But not many exceptions.
This stuff, coming from a Usenet co, sounds like a “go thru the motions and attempt to reduce the writeoff” routine and nothing more.
@PlacidPenguin
Re name format they used
Are they attempting to bill using a form of your name you have used online, attached to a matching email address? Then I would bet a buncha $ someone sold your info and someone else used it with a purchase stolen payment method and that’s what got this started.
If you think that’s likely, either ignore them, send them the sort of letter you described others sending, or have a lawyer or paralegal send them something.
If watch my credit report if this happened to me I guess.
@f00l according to one story I read about them, they sent collection letters addressed to “Occupant”. They’re just sheisty, trying to intimidate people to collect on fictitious debts, and apparently clearing millions of pounds a year doing so.
@djslack
Then they deserve to share a cage with the bad guys from some horror film. I promise to laugh.
But they did get that name and email from somewhere. Perhaps they are direct buyers of stolen data themselves. In which case it might be worth seeing if they are under investigation over there. Good to know they are assholes.
Since if they get a bad rep it will hurt their Usenet biz, I am thinking that perhaps that biz is not so profitable that they care about losing customers. They may have “pivoted”.
This thread has some good advice. The company is notorious for its practices. It’s possible that the previous occupant of your residence owes them, and they just updated to your name. It seems to be a common pattern. http://www.hotukdeals.com/ask/usenext-asking-for-unpaid-fees-2062129
@OldCatLady
Had no idea they were such pure crooks.
It’s really been awhile since I messed with Usenet.
Last week I contacted the Citizens Advice Group. As opposed to the agencies here in the US who kept on forwarding my complaint to another agency, this group just sent me a nice sized email with advice on what to do.
They also included a nice part about how this company may be violating various laws, and since there is no Central Trading Agency, if I give the sellers info, this group will give my complaint to the proper department.
@PlacidPenguin
I keep imagining that UseNext tries to collect a phony amount from an address on Elm Street and a certain notable “Mr Frederick Krueger” shows up in person to pay the bill.
/giphy Freddy Krueger