So I’d imagine if you cut up hotdogs and buns, or cut up a PB&J (or both) and threw them in cereal and added some milk, then spread the soggy mess between two pieces of bread one could ask: is this a soup sandwich or just plain gross?
PS and don’t even get us started on the pop tart ravioli soup option where you’d use pop tarts as the bread for PB&J and then… well never mind…
But I do wonder if you are soaking chocolate chip cookies in milk, or have used to be hot brownies mixed in now melted ice cream is that then soup…?
Irk explains how to make an appropriate PB&J no bananas and no fluff and definitely not butter, mayo or added sugar. Just simply old fashioned PB&J without a baseball bat.
@unksol@whomeyesu summer camp introduced me to peanut butter and marshmallow fluff (which might as well be pure sugar). Peanut butter and banana is far better. But then again mine are usually PB and honey or PB and blackberry jelly. Well it would be blackberry jelly if trader joes had had any in the last 2+ and counting years. Only get to go there a couple times a year tops and they have always been out.
And definitely not on both sides with the PB because then where can I wipe off the knife after I have spread the PB and whatever?
@Kidsandliz@unksol Actually my fav or ultimate PB&J is Peanut butter on one side of two slices of bread. Than top of the peanut butter side on just one slice add fluff. The remaining slice that has only peanut butter add your favorite jam or jelly. Cut up a banana in pretty thin slices and layer both slices covering jelly/jam than fluff with banana. Now, that’s my favorite but since it takes so long to prep. When im in a hurry i don’t add fluff or jelly/jam. I just sprinkle some sugar on top of the banana for the added sweetness…I know now you’re hungry. So am ¡!
@unksol@whomeyesu Heck why have anything good for you on it. Do it like the dutch. Bread, butter, and what we call sprinkles. Then there is bread and chocolate spread.
@Kidsandliz@unksol@whomeyesu Butter the outside and toast it like a grilled cheese sandwich. Its fantastic if you don’t mind the peanut butter getting a little runny.
@algae1221@Kidsandliz@unksol I’ve done that its good and gooey. What I haven’t had is those PB&J sandwiches sold in frozen food section deep fried. I hear that is very good. Ive tried those frozen sandwiches just thawed and they are not very good if you’re asking.
@algae1221@Kidsandliz@whomeyesu peanut butter should be gooey and for some reason I had never considered a toasted PB and banana… Both butter and mayonnaise make for good grilled sandwiches in the cast iron… On the outside of the bread… Hmmm…
Well that explains why my PB&Js never turn out well.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Is cereal a soup?
@CaptAmehrican You’re kidding, right?
Cripes, everyone knows cereal is a stew.
@CaptAmehrican @ruouttaurmind it’s a soup. and a hot dog with bun is a sandwich.
@carl669 is correct on the hotdog sandwich, but twisted and wrong about cereal.
@CaptAmehrican
Nice try Can’t find the original thread that prompted this one, however as I am sure you already know or you wouldn’t have brought it up (snicker)
https://meh.com/forum/topics/is-cereal-a-soup
And @ruouttaurmind I see that @CaptAmehrican had already asked
https://meh.com/forum/topics/is-a-hotdog-a-sandwich
and we also had
https://meh.com/forum/topics/are-hotdogs-sandwiches
So I’d imagine if you cut up hotdogs and buns, or cut up a PB&J (or both) and threw them in cereal and added some milk, then spread the soggy mess between two pieces of bread one could ask: is this a soup sandwich or just plain gross?
PS and don’t even get us started on the pop tart ravioli soup option where you’d use pop tarts as the bread for PB&J and then… well never mind…
But I do wonder if you are soaking chocolate chip cookies in milk, or have used to be hot brownies mixed in now melted ice cream is that then soup…?
@CaptAmehrican @Kidsandliz @ruouttaurmind Dipping your pbj in milk is very yummy. Soak it until just before it falls apart then eat.
Irk explains how to make an appropriate PB&J no bananas and no fluff and definitely not butter, mayo or added sugar. Just simply old fashioned PB&J without a baseball bat.
@whomeyesu wtf with butter/mayo/added sugar?
You know some… Special people… To get there
@unksol yes mayo and/or butter. I personally don’t do that yet I have heard people say that they do. So, its more popular than you think with banana.
@whomeyesu peanut butter and banana is a normal sandwich. The others… Well maybe I should try it at least once.
@unksol @whomeyesu summer camp introduced me to peanut butter and marshmallow fluff (which might as well be pure sugar). Peanut butter and banana is far better. But then again mine are usually PB and honey or PB and blackberry jelly. Well it would be blackberry jelly if trader joes had had any in the last 2+ and counting years. Only get to go there a couple times a year tops and they have always been out.
And definitely not on both sides with the PB because then where can I wipe off the knife after I have spread the PB and whatever?
@Kidsandliz @unksol @whomeyesu Why wipe the knife off when you can lick all the tasty goodness off?
@unksol @whomeyesu My mom always put butter on our PBJ’s. It’s actually pretty good. Butter. Real stuff, not margarine.
@Kidsandliz @unksol Actually my fav or ultimate PB&J is Peanut butter on one side of two slices of bread. Than top of the peanut butter side on just one slice add fluff. The remaining slice that has only peanut butter add your favorite jam or jelly. Cut up a banana in pretty thin slices and layer both slices covering jelly/jam than fluff with banana. Now, that’s my favorite but since it takes so long to prep. When im in a hurry i don’t add fluff or jelly/jam. I just sprinkle some sugar on top of the banana for the added sweetness…I know now you’re hungry. So am ¡!
@unksol @whomeyesu Heck why have anything good for you on it. Do it like the dutch. Bread, butter, and what we call sprinkles. Then there is bread and chocolate spread.
@Kidsandliz @unksol @whomeyesu Butter the outside and toast it like a grilled cheese sandwich. Its fantastic if you don’t mind the peanut butter getting a little runny.
@algae1221 @Kidsandliz @unksol I’ve done that its good and gooey. What I haven’t had is those PB&J sandwiches sold in frozen food section deep fried. I hear that is very good. Ive tried those frozen sandwiches just thawed and they are not very good if you’re asking.
@algae1221 @Kidsandliz @whomeyesu peanut butter should be gooey and for some reason I had never considered a toasted PB and banana… Both butter and mayonnaise make for good grilled sandwiches in the cast iron… On the outside of the bread… Hmmm…